AP
Нашел еще статью от Робертса. Чувак основательно угарает по кривым линиям.
В исследовании он взял Лондонскую схему. Специально ее усложнил, чтобы было труднее пользоваться. Сравнил со своей. И все равно его схема проиграла по рейтингам традиционной.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/309308877_Expectations_and_prejudices_usurp_judgements_of_schematic_map_effectiveness
A usability study is reported in which objective measures of performance were compared with subjective ratings of design effectiveness for two novel schematic London Underground maps. One of these was designed conventionally, but was deliberately intended to have complex line trajectories. The other was a novel curvilinear design, prioitised similarly. The selection of designs was motivated by a previous usability rating study in which the curvilinear map had received the lowest scores. For the current study, people planned a series of journeys using both designs. The curvilinear map yielded superior performance in terms of time to plan each journey. Despite experience with both designs, the curvilinear map still received poor usability ratings. It is suggested that expectations and prejudices about design prevent people from making accurate subjective evaluations of usability.
В исследовании он взял Лондонскую схему. Специально ее усложнил, чтобы было труднее пользоваться. Сравнил со своей. И все равно его схема проиграла по рейтингам традиционной.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/309308877_Expectations_and_prejudices_usurp_judgements_of_schematic_map_effectiveness
A usability study is reported in which objective measures of performance were compared with subjective ratings of design effectiveness for two novel schematic London Underground maps. One of these was designed conventionally, but was deliberately intended to have complex line trajectories. The other was a novel curvilinear design, prioitised similarly. The selection of designs was motivated by a previous usability rating study in which the curvilinear map had received the lowest scores. For the current study, people planned a series of journeys using both designs. The curvilinear map yielded superior performance in terms of time to plan each journey. Despite experience with both designs, the curvilinear map still received poor usability ratings. It is suggested that expectations and prejudices about design prevent people from making accurate subjective evaluations of usability.
