Size: a a a

2016 December 28

q

qtm5sian$f in English
I've seen edward snowden here, he's chilling in russia now afaik.
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
So you like are there russian here?
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
And I like yeah
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
I've seen the guy
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
^^^ the second answer stating my point basically, he's put it nicely
источник

A

Alex in English
I've already read this, haha
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
qtm5sian$f
^^^ the second answer stating my point basically, he's put it nicely
I mean the guy who wrote the second answer. You get it
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
Alex
I've already read this, haha
Oh, cool
источник

A

Alex in English
qtm5sian$f
I mean the guy who wrote the second answer. You get it
quote #1: 'When we use present perfect tense we are referring to actions which started in the past and are still happening or those actions which are finished but have an impact on the present'.
Is there any impact on the present? You just saw Edward Snowden someday.
quote #2: 'When we use simple past we refer to finished actions and those actions, results of which do not have an impact on the present.'
Seeing Edward snowden someday in the past is a finished action. No connection to now.
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
1. Yes, there is.
2. It's finished, true. It has the connection though.
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
Seriously, I don't know how to explain my train of thought better than that guy did
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
I saw a dog in the past; now, i've seen the dog.
источник

A

Alex in English
qtm5sian$f
I saw a dog in the past; now, i've seen the dog.
quote #3: 'The difference is the time period you are talking about. The Simple Past saw is used to talk about past events while the Present Perfect have seen is used to talk about things that are true now, in the present. '
What you said IS NOT true. This is a past event. You saw him, now you don't. Don't you say you see Edward Snowden right now or 1 hour ago?))
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
I'm not saying I'm watching at him right now.
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
Aahhh, how could I explain
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
Past-------------(saw him!)--------(now it's the moment after I saw him, it is true that I had seen him at the moment)--------Now
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
Like all my life splits into two periods: before I saw him and after
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
This very moment changes me once and for all, and now it is true that I have seen him indeed
источник

q

qtm5sian$f in English
Before it wasn't true, now it's true
источник